Introduction to Epilogue
More than twenty years have
passed since the main body of this book was written. During these
years, many, sometimes
surprising, developments occurred both inside and outside of
psychiatry. How relevant today are the problems of two decades ago? In
this epilogue I will show that the issues raised in my book are
presently as current as they ever were.
Developments in psychiatry as a branch of medicine are closely linked
to developments in medicine as a whole, and to developments in mental
health care. Psychiatry as a social institution develops along the
lines of processes in society as a whole.
In this epilogue I will first discuss the development of ideological
aspects in psychiatry. Here the first quandary mentioned in the preface
will return: the extent of the psychiatric realm that must be
considered relevant. These processes are mirrored to an important
degree in the way the state deals with health care, for instance
through legislation. I will discuss these, using developments in the
Netherlands as an example. Next I will discuss the current state of
affairs regarding coercion in psychiatry, as the foregoing aspects are
reflected and come together in the subject of coercion. Here the second
quandary mentioned in the preface will return: the social function of
psychiatry. Finally, returning to the question asked in the preface,
whether there can be alternatives for today’s social and psychiatric
practices, I will suggest some possible alternatives to coercion.
This epilogue is different from the previous chapters in two ways.
Firstly, in it I describe developments rather than states of affairs.
Secondly, I will be more concerned in gaining insight into these
developments than making a thorough analysis.
These aspects will be discussed also in light of developments in
Szasz’s writings.